Skip to content Skip to footer

Insurance Law: Legal Framework and Disputes

Insurance law is a branch of law that covers a wide range of areas such as insurance contracts, policies, rights of the insured and obligations of insurance companies. Insurance provides financial coverage of risks through insurance companies, and these coverages play a major role in securing the lives of the insured. However, the insurance sector can sometimes lead to various disputes regarding insurance policies and claims. Insurance law plays an important role in resolving such disputes.

Many factors come into play in insurance litigation, such as the extent to which insurance companies fulfill the terms of the policy, the extent to which they defend the rights of the insured, the size of the loss and the payment procedures. 

Litigation in insurance law determines the way in which the insured is compensated for the damage suffered by the insured, as well as how the liability of insurance companies is to be fulfilled. These cases often involve complex processes such as interpreting contracts, assessing damages and determining the amount of compensation.  

Injury and Fatal Traffic Accidents

Injury and fatal traffic accidents are one of the most important and frequently encountered areas of dispute in insurance law. Material and moral damages resulting from traffic accidents directly affect the obligations of insurance companies and the rights of the insured. Insurance lawsuits in traffic accidents involve compensation processes and the victim’s damages are determined according to the scope of the insurance policy.

Injuries or deaths resulting from a traffic accident can be covered by various types of insurance. These include motor insurance, compulsory traffic insurance and life insurance. Comprehensive insurance covers the vehicle’s own insurance and is paid by the insurance company in the event of damage to the vehicle. Compulsory traffic insurance, on the other hand, provides coverage for damages suffered by third parties. These types of insurance are important in determining the compensation rights of the victims of an accident.

As a result of traffic accidents involving injury or death, the amount of compensation to be received by the insured depends on the extent of the damage suffered by the victim and the scope of the insurance policy. The insurance company pays according to the circumstances of the incident and defends the insured’s rights arising from the accident. However, insurance companies may put various obstacles in the payment process in line with their interests, which can sometimes lead to victimization. Therefore, it is important for the victim to seek the support of a specialized lawyer to defend their legal rights.

Loss of Value Compensation

Depreciation compensation refers to compensation for the decrease in the market value of a vehicle as a result of damage to the vehicle in an accident. Even if the vehicle has been repaired, the value of the vehicle may not be the same after the accident. This type of loss of value is an important type of compensation, especially for commercial vehicle owners. In insurance law, how the loss of value compensation will be calculated and under what conditions it will be paid is determined by the provisions set out in the insurance contract.

Depreciation compensation is determined by comparing the value of the vehicle before the accident with the change in value after the accident. Insurance companies use independent expert reports to calculate the loss in value of the vehicle after repair. These reports show the difference between the post-repair value of the vehicle and its pre-accident value. This difference is paid to the insured as loss in value. However, insurance companies can often be reluctant to pay loss of value compensation. This may result in the insured needing legal assistance to defend their rights.

Disputes over loss of value compensation often center on the amount of compensation. The insurance company may want to reduce the amount of payment by understating the loss of value. At this point, the actual market value of the insured’s vehicle and the loss of value as a result of the accident must be accurately calculated. In such compensation cases, expert witnesses and lawyers are involved. Loss of value compensation is important to overcome the legal obstacles insurance companies face in fulfilling their payment obligations.

Motor Insurance Disputes

Comprehensive insurance is the vehicle’s own insurance and covers damages that occur as a result of accidents, theft, natural disasters, etc. However, there may also be various disputes regarding motor insurance. Disputes about motor insurance usually arise when the insurance company tries to reduce the amount of compensation payment or when the insured does not fulfill the terms of the policy. Such disputes are based on the details of the insurance contract and the resolution of disagreements between the insured and the insurance company.

Comprehensive insurance is provided by the insurance company in return for a premium determined according to the value of the vehicle. However, if insurance companies have difficulties in making payments as a result of accidents or keep the amount of payment low, this can lead to protracted litigation between the insured and the insurance company. Disputes within the scope of motor insurance arise particularly in the determination of the amount of compensation and the fulfillment of the terms of the policy. Attitudes of insurance companies, such as narrowing the scope of the motor insurance policy or not making payments, may lead to victimization of the insured.

In motor insurance disputes, expert witnesses and lawyers familiar with insurance law are involved between the parties. The insured must seek legal remedies in order for the insurance company to fulfill its claims and defend its rights. The insurance company must accurately assess the value of the vehicle and the damage during compensation payments.

Insurance Policy and Claims

Insurance policies are contracts signed between the insurance company and the insured that set out the responsibilities of the insurance company. The insurance policy specifies the conditions and procedures for the insured to make a claim. In the event of a claim, the insured can make a claim for compensation and the insurance company is obliged to pay according to the terms set out in the policy. However, in some cases, the insurance company may be unwilling or refuse to pay compensation.

In order for the insurance policy to be valid, all conditions specified in the policy must be fulfilled. The insured must accurately report the damage to the insurance company, complete the necessary documents and apply within the deadlines. When evaluating claims, insurance companies check whether the damage is covered by the policy. If the conditions specified in the policy are not fulfilled, the insurance company may be justified in not paying compensation. However, in this case, the insured can seek his/her rights by resorting to legal remedies.

Insurance claims can sometimes involve complex and lengthy processes. Insurance companies may give various reasons for not paying or reducing the amount of compensation. In order for the insured to protect his or her rights, it is important to carefully review the insurance policy and seek legal advice when necessary. Insurance law plays a critical role in resolving such cases.

Fire Insurance Disputes

Fire insurance is a type of insurance that protects the insured’s property from fire, explosion and other similar disasters. However, the most common disputes regarding fire insurance arise when insurance companies deny claims or when insureds fail to provide sufficient evidence of the cause of the accident. In fire insurance cases, the manner in which the fire occurred and the extent of the damage must be accurately determined.

Insurance companies examine the cause of the fire and the circumstances under which it occurred and decide whether or not to make a payment. If the fire was caused by a cause that is covered by the guarantees specified in the insurance policy, the insurance company is obliged to pay compensation. However, in some cases, the insurance company may argue that the fire is outside the scope of the insurance and refrain from paying compensation. Such disputes can lead to protracted legal litigation between the insured and the insurance company.

In fire insurance cases, it is important for the insured to provide accurate information about the location and circumstances of the fire and to submit the necessary documentation. The obligation of insurance companies to make payments begins with determining whether the damage caused by the fire is covered by the policy. To avoid victimization of the insured, the fire insurance coverage and policy terms should be carefully reviewed.

Health Insurance Disputes

Health insurance is a type of insurance to cover individuals’ medical expenses. The biggest disputes about health insurance are related to insurance companies denying payments for medical services or excluding certain health services from coverage. The insurance company decides to pay after assessing the insured’s health condition and treatment needs. However, insurance companies may sometimes refuse to pay, stating that health services are not covered by the policy.

In health insurance litigation, insureds often need to verify their illness or treatment with medical documentation. Insurance companies examine whether the treatment and health services provided by the insured are in line with the coverages specified in the policy. If the treatment is not covered by the health services specified in the policy, the insurance company may refuse to pay. In such cases, insured persons should take legal action to defend their rights.

In health insurance cases, it is important for insureds to provide accurate and complete information about their health conditions. Insurance companies may refuse to pay or limit the amount of payment based on the insured’s medical history. Insureds should legally challenge the insurance companies’ decisions and, if necessary, seek compensation.

Workplace Insurance Disputes

Workplace insurance ensures that the insurance company covers the goods and property in the workplace against disasters such as damage, theft and fire. Such insurance policies are particularly important for businesses. However, the most common disputes related to workplace insurance are related to the obstacles faced by insurance companies in identifying losses and making payments. Workplace insurance is organized to cover potential damages in the areas where businesses operate.

In the case of workplace insurance, the insurance company checks whether the damage incurred is in line with the coverages specified in the policy. However, sometimes insurance companies may refuse to pay, stating that the damage at the workplace is outside the scope of the policy. Such situations can lead to victimization of the insured. The payment terms of workplace insurance policies, especially for risks such as theft or fire, should be carefully examined.

Workplace insurance disputes often center on the extent of the damage and the insurance company’s obligations to pay. The insurance company may obtain independent appraisal reports to determine the value of the damaged goods and property. When faced with such situations, the insured should seek legal advice from a specialized lawyer to assess their claim for compensation.

Compulsory Earthquake Insurance Disputes

Compulsory earthquake insurance is a type of insurance that provides coverage for buildings against earthquakes in earthquake-prone areas of Turkey. Compulsory earthquake insurance not only provides coverage for buildings, but also provides an assurance to the insured to make the buildings earthquake resistant. However, disputes may arise in relation to buildings that are not insured against earthquakes or that have missing coverage in the policy.

Compulsory earthquake insurance lawsuits usually involve the determination of damages and the payment of compensation. Insurance companies take into account the year of construction, the structural condition of the building and the scope of the insurance policy when assessing the damages caused by the earthquake. In the earthquake insurance policy, the intensity of the earthquake, the areas of the building that are not covered by the insurance and other factors are taken into consideration. Therefore, it is important for the insured to organize their policies correctly and completely.

In earthquake insurance disputes, the claims and payment process can take a long time. The insurance company may take different views on the scope of the damage caused by the earthquake, which can lead to protracted litigation. In order to defend their rights, insured persons may resort to legal proceedings if the insurance company fails to pay compensation.

Insurance Fraud Cases

Insurance fraud cases involve insureds committing fraud in order to obtain unjust compensation from insurance companies. Insurance fraud can lead to victimization of both policyholders and insurance companies. Insurance companies carefully examine the claims of the insured against fraud and request the necessary documents to pay compensation. However, some policyholders may try to defraud insurance companies by exaggerating their losses or forging documents.

Insurance fraud cases are often associated with forgery and fraudulent documents. Insurance companies may set up special investigation units to take measures against fraud and investigate suspicious claims. It is important that insureds comply with the terms of their insurance policies and show transparency when making claims. Insurance companies also need to be vigilant to prevent fraud.